Family Care Conductor

Legal / Financial / Hiring

Workers' Comp for a Household Employee: State by State

Whether you must carry workers' comp for a caregiver depends entirely on your state, and some families cannot even buy it. How to find out where you stand.

By Published

Former employment attorney and HR director. Managing in-home care for his mom.

A woman stands in a home entryway on a phone call, taking notes on a pad beside the front door.

Disclosure: Some future product links may be affiliate links. We only plan to include related products when they are relevant to the caregiving topic.

Workers' comp for a household employee is the item private-hire families get wrong most, and there is no national answer. Two phone calls tell you where your state stands.

This is the item private-hire families get wrong most often, and it is not their fault.

There is no national answer. Workers' compensation for household employees is governed state by state, the rules are genuinely inconsistent, and the people you would naturally ask often do not know.

So here is how to figure out where you actually stand.

Does Workers' Comp Cover a Private Caregiver?

Workers' compensation pays an employee's medical bills and a portion of lost wages when they are injured doing their job. In exchange, it is generally the exclusive remedy, which means the employee is compensated through the system rather than by suing you personally.

That last clause is the part families should care about most. Workers' compensation is not only protection for the caregiver. It is the thing standing between you and a very bad afternoon.

Caregiving is physical work. Lifting an adult, catching a fall, a wet bathroom floor, a set of stairs, a dog underfoot. Injuries in this field are common, and back injuries most of all.

The Four Possibilities in Your State

Required. Some states require coverage for household employees at surprisingly low thresholds, measured in hours worked per week or dollars paid per quarter. A part-time caregiver two days a week can be enough to trigger it.

Optional but strongly advisable. Many states do not require it for household employees but permit you to buy it voluntarily. Voluntary coverage still gets you the exclusive remedy protection, which is the entire reason to bother.

Required only above a threshold you may cross later. Watch this one. Families that add hours over time can drift across a line nobody told them about.

Practically unavailable. This is the frustrating case. Families have reported calling carrier after carrier and being unable to find anyone willing to write a policy for a single household employee, even where the state permits it. Small residual markets and state funds exist in some places, but the search can be genuinely difficult.

How to Get the Answer in Two Calls

Call your state's workers' compensation board or division. Every state has one and the phone number is public. Ask the question in exactly these words: am I required to carry workers' compensation for a household employee working a certain number of hours a week in a private residence.

Then call the agent who writes your homeowners policy. Ask two things. Whether they can add a workers' compensation endorsement for a household employee, and what your existing policy does and does not cover if a domestic worker is injured on the property.

Write down the answers with the date and who told you. That record is worth having.

Why Homeowners Insurance Is Not the Backstop

A lot of families assume their homeowners policy covers this. Sometimes there is limited medical payments coverage that helps with a small injury.

But many homeowners policies specifically exclude injuries to domestic employees, particularly where the state expected you to carry workers' compensation and you did not. Some carriers offer an endorsement that adds it. Some will not, especially in states with an active requirement.

Do not assume. Ask, in writing, and keep the reply.

If You Genuinely Cannot Buy It

Some families end up here, and the honest answer is that there is no clean solution. There are only reasonable steps.

Reduce the risk of injury directly. Grab bars, a shower chair, a transfer belt, good lighting, non-slip mats, a mechanical lift if transfers are heavy. This is the highest-value thing on the list and it also makes your parent safer.

Never ask one person to do a two-person transfer. Most serious caregiver injuries come from exactly that.

Ask your insurance agent about an in-home care or domestic worker endorsement, and ask a second agent if the first says no. Availability varies more than you would expect.

Consider an agency for the physically heavy shifts specifically. The agency carries the coverage, and you can keep a private caregiver for the lighter work.

Talk to an employment attorney in your state for one hour. This is a narrow, answerable question, and it is worth an hour of somebody's time.

The Uncomfortable Reality

The worst version of this is the family paying cash, with no policy, in a state that required one, when the caregiver falls down the basement stairs.

That is a medical bill with no coverage, an unreported employment relationship that just became visible, and a person with a real injury who has no other way to be made whole.

The next post in this series is entirely about that scenario, because it deserves its own.

What to Do This Week

Make the two phone calls. They take about twenty minutes together.

Buy the coverage if it is available, whether or not your state requires it.

Fix the physical hazards regardless.

This is general information, not legal advice, and the rules are truly state-specific. Get your own state's answer from your own state.

It is twenty minutes now against a problem you cannot fix later.

Read next:

You Just Became an Employer. Nobody Told You.

Nanny Tax for Caregivers: The Simple Version